|
When I first started the book I asked a Vietnam vet I know if he had read it. Although Mr. I stopped reading about 1/3 of the way through. He looked at me and said "you won't like it-I didn't". O'Brien is a gifted writer, he seems to wallow in the absolutely worst aspects of the Vietnam experience. Since this book is required reading in many high schools, I was doubly upset. Since he never talks about his experience, he would not elaborate. I have since learned from someone who went to a question and answer session with the author, that he admitted that a lot of the book was fiction, and would not even say whether or not he had ever served in Vietnam.
You'll experience emotions like you never have before. This book is not just another story about a soldier in Vietman. Tim O'Brien's words make you feel as though you truly were there. A brilliant story. war and its soldiers we should never forget.
This thoughtful and elegantly written book gave true insight into the people who were there. I sent it to my son who is serving in Iraq.
This is an assumption since I have no idea of the hardships soldiers faced in Vietnam. The Things They Carried by Tim O'Brien is a work of fiction and a masterpiece of literature. He carries the reader through a series of obscure and deliberate stories about the emotions and actions soldiers faced in the Vietnam war. I think the feeling of uneasiness the reader gets is supposed to act as a mirror to what the soldiers felt throughout the war. This is a book that should continue to be taught in high school english classes because it requires a lot of deep and critical thinking to figure out what O'Brien is trying to say through his collection of uncomfortable short stories.Read it. The problem many readers have with this book is that it is never clear what is true and what is false.
Tim O'Brien writes in a very unique and engaging prose that makes this novel a quick read. The fact that it is a work of fiction left O'Brien with infinite artistic and literary integrity in determining the events that transpired, or never transpired, for that matter. The book is a very good book to read if you are aspiring to be a writer. O'Brien stresses the point that it does not matter if a specific story actually happened, because it did happen. Maybe in a different context, or a different scene, but the irresolute feeling of trying to piece together what did or didn't happen is a major theme of the book. It must not be simply skimmed through though because then a lot of meaning would be lost.
It will make you think.
This book is fiction, yet I see comments from readers stating that the book helped them understand the war. I read about 100 pages and toss it in the trash. You cannot read this book and believe that you have a better understanding of the war and the soldiers that fought there. This fiction adds to the falsehoods/myths already written about the war, and unfortunately, some people believe it as fact. It's disgusting that some continue to spread falsehoods about the Vietnam War. If you must read it, enjoy the FICTION, but never take what you read in this book as FACT.
|